Does Science Disprove the Resurrection?

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Apologetics Booklet Examines Factual Evidence of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ.

How does one go about finding a true answer to the question of whether Jesus did or didn’t rise from the dead?

As we said when we started this blog series, a critical historian would check out the validity of the records of witnesses, confirm Jesus’ death by crucifixion, go over the burial procedures, and confirm the reports of the empty tomb and Jesus being seen alive on the third day—and then consider possible alternative explanations of the event. 

It is my hope, as you looked closely at the crucifixion details, the burial details, the empty tomb, and some of the faulty resurrection theories critics have proposed, that your faith in Christ’s resurrection has been strengthened. Christ rose, just as He promised!

We’ll finish up this blog series by recapping seven important points we’ve learned about the resurrection, and answer this question: Does science disprove the resurrection?

Seven Key Points We’ve Learned From This Resurrection Series:Resurrection of Jesus

  • We’ve learned that numerous non-Biblical sources confirm that Jesus livedand died on a cross, before being buried to exacting Jewish custom.
  • The Jewish leaders responsible for His death did everything they could to thwart Jesusincluding spreading the lie that His body was stolen and His resurrection faked.
  • That crowds of people saw Jesus in His resurrected form. The apostle Paul records that many of those witnesses were still alive (and thus able to deny the resurrection) at the time of his writing. Remember that Paul, originally named Saul, despised Christ and persecuted His followersuntil Paul’s radical conversion. After that, he wouldn’t shut up about the Good News of Jesus’ resurrection!
  • Even James, who did not believe in Jesus when He was alive, became a radical believerand one of the Church’s early martyrs. What caused such a change in his attitude toward his brother? Seeing Jesus resurrected!
  • We’ve learned that early Christ followers were so convinced of Jesus’ resurrection that they enthusiastically shared the Good Newsdespite the threat of death. Many willingly gave their lives for Jesus.
  • That critics have spent considerable time coming up with resurrection theories so full of holes that they resemble Swiss cheese. It takes more faith to believe in them than the resurrection!
  • That we believe in Christ as Savior because God has opened our hearts and minds to the truth. We do not follow Christ because we need a “crutch” to deal with life, or because we’re delusional. After we personally experience the truth of the resurrection, we can so clearly see the lies the world spins as “truth.”

Does the Big Bang Theory Work for You???

So, let’s talk science. When Jesus rose from the grave, the miraculous happened. Yet Science loves to tell us that miracles don’t happen. That a man simply can’t rise from death. That the world can’t possibly have a creator. That God doesn’t exist. That only science can prove “truth.”  

But let’s remember that fact and theory are not the same thing. The first is, well, fact. The second is guesswork. The details of Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection, in both the Bible and non-Christian texts, are FACT. We can trust them.

Though we don’t often hear the scientific community publicly saying so, it’s important to remember that many scientists are open to the plausibility of the resurrection. In his article Can a Scientist believe in the Resurrection?, MIT Professor Ian Hutchinson writes:

“My Christian colleagues at MIT—and millions of other scientists worldwide—somehow think that a literal miracle like the resurrection of Jesus is possible. And we are following a long tradition. Today’s widespread materialist view that events contrary to the laws of science just can’t happen is a metaphysical doctrine, not a scientific fact.”

After adding that “the fact that the resurrection was impossible in the normal course of events was as obvious in the first century as it is for us. Indeed that is why it was seen as a great demonstration of God’s power,” Hutchinson asserts:

So if science is not able to adjudicate whether Jesus’ resurrection happened or not, are we completely unable to assess the plausibility of the claim? No. Contrary to increasingly popular opinion, science is not our only means for accessing truth. In the case of Jesus’ resurrection, we must consider the historical evidence, and the historical evidence for the resurrection is as good as for almost any event of ancient history. The extraordinary character of the event, and its significance, provide a unique context, and ancient history is necessarily hard to establish. But a bare presumption that science has shown the resurrection to be impossible is an intellectual cop-out. Science shows no such thing.”

The comments posted to Hutchinson’s article make for a fascinating read. You might peruse them, if you find intellectual comments between Christians and non-Christians to be as interesting as I do.

One of the commenters, a woman who admits that she gave up religion because those who follow it are “childish” and “ridiculous” and “irrational,” writes: “It takes no faith to reject supernatural claims that have neither a logical nor evidential basis.”

The simple truth: this obviously scientifically educated woman has yet to grasp that she will not experience the truth and power of the resurrection until she approaches God with an open heart and mind. God continually offers us the opportunity to meet Him and know Him. But He will never force the relationship.

Are Atheists Right to Dismiss God and the Resurrection?

Hmmm…..the Bible says that we’re all born with an innate knowledge of our need for God. Atheists, from my experience, are so strident in their stance because of their personal life experiences with this very tough world. Their hurts, their disappointments, their anger, and their fears appear to be the impetus for their choosing to sit in judgment of God.

In a video highlighting an interview with atheist Stephen Fry, Fry asserts that God is “mean-minded” and “stupid” and “monstrous.” Fry says he would ask this question of God: “How dare you? How dare you create a world in which there is such misery that is not our fault?” Fry later says, “The moment you banish Him, your life becomes simpler, purer, cleaner, more worth living.”

That’s quite the leap. And untrue. We all know people who have been radically transformed after choosing to place their lives in God’s hands. Why does God allow children to get cancer? I don’t know the answer to Fry’s question. But I also don’t have to know the answeror find the answer acceptableto believe in God or His goodness. Is God accountable to me? Umm…no. He’s God. Our arrogance in demanding that God exist in the boxes we create for Him is astounding.

Another atheist, theoretical physicist Sean Carroll, believes that if a good God existed, He would have made it easy for us to accept Him by providing a single manual for mankind:

“If God existed, if there were an omnipotent being that cared about us on earth, I would expect clear instructions. I would expect a book that I knew exactly what it said, it was clear that it was right and I would be able to follow it. If God did not exist, I would expect all sorts of different books. They would contradict each other, some of them would be brilliant in parts, they’d be silly in other parts, they’d be uplifting in parts, they’d be very depressing in other parts, they’d be edited collections, they’d be personal memoirs, and they’d all disagree with each other. Which of these two theories fits the data?”

Can I get an “Amen,” that the confusion is on our part, not God’s? The religious splintering in our world doesn’t make God happy either. The CliffsNotes version of His plan: “Love God, love each other.” Yet, we consistently choose to do the opposite.

Fry suggests, as did the woman in Hutchinson’s article, that Christians are incapable of intelligent thought. I think we can all agree that there are some “Christians” who do not seem to put much thought into what they think, say, or do.

But I also know many Christ followers who are highly intelligent, and highly committed to seeking God and knowing Him by studying His Word. They don’t try to make God fit into their theory of who He should be, but allow Him to reveal who He is. Atheists believe their intelligence and logic trumps God’s, that the resurrection never happened, and so it holds no meaning.

Bottom line: Through His resurrection, Jesus gives us the freedom that God originally intended. Without the resurrection, we have nothing to lift us out of the muck of this very fallen world. But by defeating death, Jesus showed us that our earthly experience is just part of our journey in our relationship with God. There’s so much good to come!

Will YOU Make Room for the Miraculous?

As Quaker author Anthony Manousos writes in his 2013 blog article Scientists Prove Jesus Rose From the Dead!:

“Resurrection from the dead is not in and of itself good news. If you lack faith in God, if you have never experienced the wonder and mystery of the Divine, then even a seeming miracle like resurrection becomes just another fact.” He adds, “Yet for some, there is still the desire to know “beyond a reasonable doubt” if the Gospel story is true. How can one prove the resurrection “beyond a reasonable doubt” to someone who has not experienced the risen Christ?”

Adds Manousos:

“Suppose that not nine but hundreds, thousands of witnesses, claim that they experienced something they called ‘the risen Christ. This, of course, is not hypothetical. This is what happened in the early days of Christianity, and continues to happen to this day. Ordinary men and women became willing to sacrifice their lives in the belief that they had this transforming and empowering experience. Does this prove conclusively that Christ rose from the dead?”

Manousos concludes that it does. But he rightly adds that we each must choose to make that decision.

Is now the time for YOU to meet Jesus? You might start with this link: How Can I know Jesus personally?

death and rise of Jesus


This blog post highlights Josh and Sean’s new 64-page booklet, The Resurrection and You. We are certain this little booklet will be an effective evangelism tool for you this Easter season. So we’d like to offer you this resource, to help you share the Good News! BONUS: Every 30-pack order arrives with a FREE copy of our full, 256-page book, Evidence for the Resurrection.

Tags: , , , ,